Coursebook Evaluation on Social Justice

Posted On 2/7/2019 9:10:00 PM, 2Comments

Textbooks are the main materials used in the classrooms to teach any field in education. Learners mostly get the necessary information from those materials by following up the themes in them. Thus, what is written in those is fundamental for the learners throughout the learning process. Any information written ought to be authentic and fair for each learner. If the government provides its citizens with social justice, it should cover the field of education, as well. The contents of the textbooks used in the schools must be checked in case there is any topic which reflects some inequality or injustice in the textbooks.

There are many topics such as nature, greetings, cultures, sports, festivals, and climate in the books and those topics need to be told authentically. For example, a course book, called Enterprise 3 by Express Publishing, is used as an additional source in an English class. The course book level is pre-intermediate and it is the 3rd edition. In the 22nd unit of the course book, on page 99, the writing section consists of listening about some inventors and their inventions. The students are asked to fill the blanks in the table and write their own projects about those inventors and their inventions. When the students look at the table, they see that all the inventors are males e.g. Galileo, A. Graham Bell, Thomas Edison, Karl Benz, and the Wright brothers. Why did the course book not contain any female inventor like Marie Curie, inventor of the theory of radioactivity to the table? Students need to know both female and male inventors, not only males. They also need to learn women may become what they want, an inventor or a scientist because those pictures provide the students to perceive the models or the roles of the people in the society. Thus, they should be designed well and the content of the course book should be fair for both female and male learners.

 

                  

Comments (2) -

Adnan Yilmaz
2/23/2019 6:01:00 AM #

Vildan, I totally agree with you that a social justice problem regarding gender equality exists in the example you provided. The table including the photos of the inventors clearly and explicitly shows this social justice problem. Surely, as you mentioned, this problem should be handled seriously, and females and males should be given equal room in textbooks.

However, I wonder if you have seen any other parts or unites that focus on or can be related to social justice. What strong and weak points have you seen in relation to social justice in the book? What other problems have you seen in the book in terms of social justice?

Bill Snyder
2/25/2019 7:52:32 PM #

Hi Vildan,

I agree with a lot of your general critique of coursebook design. The issue of fairness in representation is an important one to consider when we work on materials. And I think the example you present is a case where this has not been done.

You make another point about the use of materials like this, that they are really only the basis for "following up" by the teacher and students. And this following up is key to countering the limits of the materials we have to work with. How would you go about following this activity up to achieve the goal of fairness and inclusion that you advocate? I have some ideas but I'd like to hear from you first. I think we can have an interesting discussion about this.

Like Adnan hoca, I'd also like to hear more about how you include social justice education more widely across other units of the coursebook. Do you think it is possible to include social justice education in some form in all units? Or does it only work with certain themes?

I'm lookinng forward to meeting you and other members of this program when I come to Turkey and talking more about these topics.

Add comment

Vildan Kurtoglu

4th year student in English Language Teaching at Sakarya University